After spending considerable time researching and experimenting with various smart switches and dimmers, I wanted to share my findings and experiences with the community. My goal was to find devices that could operate locally without relying on cloud services, which is crucial for reliability and security in my setup.
I started with Tuya-based devices, which worked well initially. However, the shift to RTL controllers made flashing with open firmware like Tasmota nearly impossible. This was a significant setback, as I relied on these devices for their flexibility. Despite this, I managed to successfully flash some older Tuya devices, which still function perfectly in my system.
Recently, I came across the Shelly One, which has been a game-changer. Its local control capabilities, combined with MQTT integration, have made it a reliable addition to my setup. The UI is user-friendly, and the option to use local or cloud-based control is a huge plus. However, Shelly doesn’t offer wall switches or dimmers, which limits its applicability for certain projects.
In my search for local control options, I’ve also explored Gosund and TreatLife devices. While they have potential, confirming the chipset used in newer models is challenging, which makes me cautious about long-term reliability. The move away from ESP-based controllers is a concern, as it reduces the ability to customize and control these devices locally.
One of my key criteria for any new device is UL or ETL listing, ensuring safety and quality. I also prefer simple, sleek designs that blend seamlessly into my home decor. The ability to support 3-way control is another essential feature, given the layout of my home.
I’ve had some success with ESP-based devices, but the uncertainty around newer models is a hurdle. I’m hopeful that manufacturers will continue to offer open firmware options or provide better documentation for local control setups.
To others embarking on similar projects, I recommend starting with devices known for their open firmware support and ensuring you have the necessary tools for flashing and configuration. Testing in a controlled environment before full integration can save time and frustration.
This journey has been both challenging and rewarding, and I’m eager to hear how others have navigated similar challenges in their smart home setups. Let’s continue to explore and innovate together!