Successfully Resolving Smart Lighting Automation Timeframe Issue

I recently encountered an issue with my smart lighting automation setup that I thought I’d share with you all, along with the solution I discovered. It’s been a bit of a journey, but I’m happy to say I’ve got it sorted out!

So, the problem was this: I set up an automation where my Sengled Element smart light turns on whenever my Schlage Connect smart lock is unlocked. The light stays on for three minutes before turning off. This part worked perfectly—yea! The challenge came when I tried to restrict this automation to a specific timeframe. I wanted it to only execute between sunset and sunrise. However, no matter what timeframe I entered in the settings, the automation ignored it completely. I could unlock the door at any time outside that window, and the light would still come on. It was quite frustrating, especially since I tested it with a smart plug, and the same issue occurred.

After some research and troubleshooting, I realized the issue wasn’t with the bulb or the plug but with how the timeframe was being interpreted. I came across some forum discussions and documentation that suggested the ‘Only during a certain time’ option might not be functioning as intended in my setup. This led me to explore alternative methods to enforce the timeframe restriction.

I decided to take a closer look at the rules and triggers in my smart home system. Through some experimentation, I discovered that manually setting up a cron job for the automation worked perfectly. By defining the exact times I wanted the automation to activate, I bypassed the problematic timeframe setting. It was a bit of a workaround, but it got the job done!

Here’s a quick breakdown of what I did:

  1. Identify the Issue: The automation was ignoring the specified timeframe.
  2. Research: Looked into forum posts and documentation to understand potential causes.
  3. Experimentation: Tried different settings and explored alternative methods.
  4. Solution: Set up a cron job to manually define the activation times.

It’s been a week since I implemented this fix, and everything has been running smoothly. The light now only activates during the sunset to sunrise window, and it consistently turns off after three minutes. It’s a relief to have this automation working as intended, and it’s been a great learning experience in troubleshooting and customizing smart home setups.

If anyone else is facing similar issues, I’d recommend checking your automation triggers, exploring alternative methods, and not hesitating to reach out to the community for advice. Sometimes a fresh perspective or a different approach can make all the difference!

Happy automating everyone! :rocket: