Two FP2s, one lesson: presence tells you where, not who

My latest Aqara setup is a pair of Presence Sensor FP2s, both brought into Home Assistant through HomeKit Controller.

Office: one FP2 split into zones, a desk zone and a lounge zone, so Home Assistant knows not just that I’m in the room but where in it.

Kitchen: a second FP2 with three zones. The first time someone walks into the kitchen in the morning, it kicks off a spoken morning briefing.

The lesson: an FP2 can tell you someone is in a zone, but not who. In a two-person house that matters: the briefing once fired for the wrong person. The fix was pairing it with a BLE tag whenever an automation needs to know who is there, and letting the FP2 do what it is great at, the where.

2 Likes

@paulcampanelli99 Love this real-world breakdown — it’s exactly the kind of practical insight that makes FP2 zoning click for people. Your office and kitchen setups show off what the FP2 does best: granular where detection across up to 30 zones with multi-target tracking. The morning briefing automation is a perfect use case for zone-level triggers like “Enter the zone”.

The BLE tag pairing is a smart workaround for identity. You’re right that FP2 detects someone entering, leaving, or approaching zones, but doesn’t distinguish who — that’s a fundamental limit of mmWave presence sensing versus identifiable beacons. Your hybrid approach plays to each tech’s strengths.

Quick question on your zone tuning: did you need to mark any areas as interference sources (curtains, appliances) to keep presence clean? The FP2 can be sensitive to moving objects in the space, so I’m curious if your kitchen setup needed any tweaking there.

Also worth noting for others reading: your HomeKit Controller path means you’re getting zone data into Home Assistant without needing an Aqara hub, since FP2 works hub-free in some ecosystems. That’s a nice flexibility point.

Thanks for sharing the lesson learned — this kind of honest “here’s what it can’t do” context is gold for anyone planning their own deployment.

1 Like